Remember when everyone was ripping out their closed cabinetry and opting for floating shelves? Whether you embraced this trend or watched skeptically, the moment of reckoning has arrived. Those who ditched closed cabinetry for the airy look and convenience of floating shelves are now rethinking their choices, realizing that a bit more privacy for their kitchen wares might be preferable. To discuss the pros and cons of this polarizing trend, we turn to Louisa Roberts, owner of Neat Method NYC, and Meg Markland of Neat by Meg.
Floating shelves certainly had their moment in the sun, offering an open, stylish look that many homeowners found appealing. However, the reality of everyday functionality has led to a shift back towards closed cabinetry. “I think that floating shelves sound great in theory, but the reality is they are not as functional as closed cabinets,” says Markland. “No one wants their chipped ‘My Favorite Dad’ coffee mug on display at all times.”
For those still enamored with the aesthetic of floating shelves, there are ways to balance style and practicality. Utilizing other closed storage areas within the kitchen and pantry can help maintain the clean look of floating shelves without sacrificing functionality. Drawers, lower cabinets, and nearby closets can store everyday items out of sight while keeping the open shelves for the prettier, less-used items.
The appeal of floating shelves lies in their appearance and convenience. They offer a grab-and-go solution that makes tasks like unloading the dishwasher quicker and easier. However, when it comes to storing less visually appealing items such as storage containers and water bottles, floating shelves fall short. “With closed cabinetry, we can truly place kitchen items based on functionality without worrying about the aesthetic impact,” Roberts explains. “For example, if the homeowner wants reusable water bottles near the refrigerator, we have the option to do that with closed cabinetry—not so much with open shelving.”
Markland adds that an aesthetic-focused storage system in the kitchen limits where items can be placed. While floating shelves may suit those with a minimalist lifestyle or a strong preference for form over function, many homeowners find themselves needing the versatility and practicality that closed cabinetry provides.
In conclusion, while floating shelves offer a trendy, open look that can make a kitchen feel more spacious, their lack of practicality for everyday storage is leading many homeowners back to the tried-and-true functionality of closed cabinetry. As with any design choice, balancing aesthetics and practicality is key to creating a kitchen that not only looks good but works well for everyday life.
