Remember when everyone was ripping out their closed cabinetry and opting for floating shelves? Whether you embraced the trend or predicted its fleeting nature, the time has come to reassess. Those who swapped their closed cabinets for floating shelves are starting to realize the benefits of more concealed storage. Experts Louisa Roberts of Neat Method NYC and Meg Markland of Neat by Meg weigh in on this divisive topic.
Functionality Can Be Limited
While floating shelves have had their moment, many homeowners now crave more functionality in their kitchens. We need spaces for everyday items like water bottles, kids’ dishes, and quirky coffee mugs, not just the pretty platters. “Floating shelves sound great in theory, but they aren’t as functional as closed cabinets,” says Markland. No one wants their chipped “My Favorite Dad” mug on display at all times. To balance style and practicality, you can use other closed storage areas like drawers and lower cabinets for the less aesthetically pleasing items.
Aesthetics First
Floating shelves undeniably prioritize appearances. Their grab-and-go appeal is balanced by the visual interest they add to a kitchen. A stack of dishes near the stove makes dinner prep easy, and unloading the dishwasher is a breeze. However, storing less attractive items like plastic containers and water bottles can become a challenge. “With closed cabinetry, we can place kitchen items based on functionality without worrying about aesthetics,” says Roberts. An aesthetic-driven storage system can limit where you place items, but minimalists and those who favor form over function might still appreciate the look of floating shelves.
Creating Balance
A mix of open and closed shelving can offer a balanced look. Incorporating floating shelves can break up bulky cabinetry and add visual interest. Open shelves can introduce another color or material, complement painted cabinetry, or showcase a backsplash from countertop to ceiling. This mix provides practicality while maintaining a stylish kitchen.
Organizational Challenges
When it comes to organization, closed cabinetry often wins. “None of the organizational items look great on open shelving where you want a curated and streamlined appearance,” says Markland. Closed cabinets allow for color-coded systems, bins, and baskets without worrying about aesthetics. You can store miscellaneous items efficiently, letting your organizational skills shine without compromising on style.
Space Considerations
In smaller kitchens, upper cabinets can make the space feel even more cramped. “In smaller kitchens, adding open shelves or ledges can be more helpful than closed shelving,” explains Roberts. Floating shelves add storage without making the space feel cluttered and can embrace the charm of a smaller kitchen. However, if you struggle with organization and dusting, open shelves might not be for you. They require more maintenance and restraint to keep things tidy and visually appealing.
Additional Considerations
While floating shelves have been trendy, homeowners are shifting back to closed cabinetry for a more functional approach. For those wanting the best of both worlds, Markland suggests incorporating upper cabinets with glass fronts. This allows you to display favorite items while hiding less attractive ones. Ultimately, Roberts says, “The classics will always find their way back into homes,” emphasizing the enduring appeal of traditional closed cabinetry.
